American Masai

Posted by: Steve Belasco
Published on August 17th, 2009 @ 04:25:41 pm , using 494 words
Category: Commentary

We read this morning that the administration is considering compromising its public health insurance option. It is feeling the pressure of public sentiment which is running against change or, at least, that particular change. I am reminded of President Julius Nyerere’s comments on his efforts to bring modern development to the Masai, those tall, resilient, culturally distinct people of East Africa known to Europeans and their North American descendents for standing on one leg and drinking a mixture of cattle blood and urine. Modern development was seen by some as a threat to the Masai way of life and President Nyerere was questioned about the potentially destructive impact on the Masai of his modernization efforts. Nyerere responded that there was tremendous pressure on everyone to live in the 20th Century and “everyone” included the Masai. He noted that it wasn’t a matter of choice. People were either going to live in the 20th Century with the flow or they were going to live in the 20th Century against the flow. No one, Nyerere added, gets to choose not to live in the 20th Century. It was not his doing. He was simply trying to get his people on board the train.

It appears that we have our own Masai problem right here in the U. S. Change is always difficult for humans. People prefer the known and generally fear the unknown. The unknown can be tricky. Watch one of my elderly brethren try to use a debit card to get gasoline and you will see what I mean. What comes easily and naturally to some is strange and inexplicably complicated to others. But the world we live in now requires us to have debit/credit cards and refusing them is not one of the choices.

Eventually we will have national health care. We can start having it now or we can start having it later. But we will have it just as we will have to live in the 21st Century. In the meantime, we have our Masai and our Masai don’t want to live in the 21st Century. They want to live in the early 20th Century. And who can blame them? Those quiet small towns with tree lined streets. The calm, the peace, the people looking out for one another. The doctor making housecalls. Ah, yesteryear. And, as we are seeing, our Masai can be fierce in their opposition to change. And as between logic on the one hand and passion and ferocity the other, well, the outcome is never in doubt. So, although there is still hope for some small inroad, it would appear that we will largely continue to limp along with our expensive, profit heavy, but familiar private health insurance until it simply collapses of its own weight. National health care is not a panacea. It’s simply what the 21st Century will require of organizations called nations. Meantime, we will continue to live in the land of the fee.

 

2 comments

Comment from: Bill Pearlman [Member] Email
Good post. It is always helpful to get a view of another condition paralleling our own, and find some way to make sense of the unsensible. Kesey used to talk about screwing the inscrutable. Same difference. Yes, the way we do things has been to make a terrible mess of health care. But amazingly, even so-called intelligent folks find themselves resistig even the obviously positive changes that will indeed come, now or later.
08/17/09 @ 17:04
Comment from: Stace Johnson [Member] Email
Excellent post, Steve. Thanks for putting this so eloquently.

Personally, I'm not willing to pronounce the public option dead until it's clearly been bypassed. I have to hope.

Normally, I'm not a party-line advocate, but in this case, I wish the Democrats had stuck to the party line, rather than trying to reach a compromise. Either that, or I wish the GOP had been more willing to compromise in the health care arena.

As it is, it appears that the GOP has been sticking to its guns (so to speak), looking the other way while its constituents do the dirty work, and dragging a few Dems down with them.
08/17/09 @ 19:40

Leave a comment


Your email address will not be revealed on this site.

Your URL will be displayed.
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Name, email & website)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will not be revealed.)